Executive Team

Caitlin Scheinblum

Chief Underwriting Officer

Caitlin Scheinblum, Chief Underwriting Officer


As Chief Underwriting Officer for People’s Trust Insurance and member of the Executive Committee, Caitlin relies on almost two decades of insurance experience to lead and establish strategic direction for our company’s underwriting department. She focuses on streamlining departmental operations, enhancing underwriting tools, and relying on practical knowledge to be an instrumental part of the growth, success, and culture at People’s Trust.


Prior to joining People’s Trust in 2016, Caitlin gained her insurance industry knowledge at State Farm Insurance, progressing through positions of increased responsibility in commercial underwriting roles in Florida and Illinois, including on-site field underwriting inspections and consulting agents on sales tactics and retention strategies to grow their commercial book of business.


Caitlin applies a humanized approach to the People’s Trust Underwriting Department, which enhances the effectiveness of her team as well as the experience for agents and customers.


Growing up in Miami, Caitlin experienced firsthand the life-changing events of Hurricane Andrew which inspired her passion for the insurance industry. She is a graduate of Florida State University with dual Bachelor of Science degrees in Multinational Business Operations and Applied Economics.